Chapter 2 - The House on Orchard Lane
Twelve-twenty Orchard Lane was the kind of house that appeared on regional historical home tours. It was a Federalist-style brick colonial, wrapped in mature boxwood hedges and framed by ancient weeping willows that Judith insisted on having pruned twice a year by specialists brought down from Lancaster.
Inside, the lights were blazing.
Sloane was on her knees in the entryway, scrubbing the hardwood with an old terrycloth bath towel soaked in warm water and Murphy’s Oil Soap. Her cashmere sweater was rolled to the elbows. Her hands were raw, red from the hot water, but her face was taut with manic energy.
“It’s not lifting,” Sloane hissed, scrubbing at a dark, stubborn stain between the grooved joints of the parquet. “Mother, the oak is porous. She bled right into the seam!”
Judith stood by the antique sideboard, sipping from a fresh tumbler of bourbon. She hadn't bothered to pour it into a wineglass; the previous set was now short one piece, and the jagged shards had already been swept into a double-lined plastic trash bag sitting by the kitchen island.
“Use the hydrogen peroxide under the bathroom sink,” Judith said coldly, not turning around. “And stop hyperventilating. You sound like a child.”
“She drove away, Mother! Her head was split open and she got into that car! What if she crashed? What if she called Uncle Robert? What if she went to the police?”
“Paige does not go to the police,” Judith said, taking a measured sip. Her voice had the absolute, unshakeable confidence of a woman who had broken a child's spirit incrementally, day by day, for twenty-nine continuous years. “Paige is weak. She has always been weak. She will drive around the block, cry until she runs out of breath, and then she will check into an urgent care clinic, tell them she tripped over the garden hose, and come back here with her tail between her legs.”
“And the apartment?” Sloane demanded, her chest heaving as she stood up, tossing the bloodied rag into the bucket. “Her lease starts Monday. The bank accounts, Mother! The signature card on the joint operating account—if she’s not here on Monday, how do we cover the balloon payment on the estate tax?”
Judith didn't flinch. “She will be here. When she walks through that door, we do not shout. We do not apologize. We tell her that her hysteria caused an accident, that she frightened both of us, and that until she shows she is mentally stable, her financial power of attorney will be transferred to me. I’ve already drafted the letter to Arthur Byrne.”
“And if she refuses?”
Judith looked at her eldest daughter with flat, pale eyes. “She won't refuse. She cannot survive without this family. She has no friends, no connections, and nowhere to lay her head that isn't paid for with Merritt money.”
It was precisely at that second that the blue and red lights began to splash against the drawn damask curtains.
There had been no sirens. The squad cars had rolled up the long, crushed-gravel driveway with their lights flashing in silent, pulsing waves of crimson and sapphire.
Sloane froze, the damp towel dangling from her hand.
“Mother?”
Judith set her tumbler on the mahogany table with a sharp *clink*. For the first time all evening, a thin, razor-sharp crack appeared in her aristocratic facade.
“Put the bucket in the powder room,” Judith commanded, her voice dropping an octave. “Now. Sloane, take down your hair. Unbutton your top collar. If anyone asks, she attacked you. She was manic. She threw the glass at you, missed, and fell against the corner of the credenza.”
“Can they check for fingerprints?” Sloane’s voice climbed into an octave of sheer panic.
“Do as I tell you!”
Judith smoothed her lilac cardigan, ran a hand over her pristine gray hair, and walked toward the entrance. She took a slow, deep breath, arranging her features into the perfect portrait of an aging, terrified mother whose troubled daughter had just experienced a nervous breakdown.
She unlocked the deadbolt—the very lock she had engaged three hours earlier—and pulled the heavy six-panel door wide open.
Standing on the flagstone porch were four uniform officers and a woman in a charcoal overcoat with a detective’s gold shield clipped to her lapel. Behind them, three patrol cruisers sat idling on the gravel, their high-intensity searchlights bathing the front of the colonial in blinding white illumination.
“Judith Merritt?” Detective Vance asked. Her hair was pulled back into a short, efficient ponytail, her dark eyes scanning the foyer behind Judith with predatory precision.
“Yes,” Judith said, her voice instantly dropping into that soft, fragile, tremulous register she used whenever the county tax assessor visited. “Officers, thank God. Did you find her? Is my Paige all right? We have been beside ourselves with worry—she had an episode, she was so confused, she fell—”
“Mrs. Merritt,” Detective Vance interrupted, stepping past the threshold without waiting for an invitation. Her boots left damp imprints on the parquet. “Where is your daughter Sloane?”
Sloane emerged from the hallway, her face pale, her hands trembling—though this time, the fear was entirely genuine.
“I’m here,” Sloane stammered. “Paige... she attacked me. She was screaming about her apartment, and she grabbed a glass from the table—”
Detective Vance didn’t let her finish. She glanced down at the floor. Even with the scrubbing, the faint, rust-colored shadow of my blood remained etched into the porous grain of the oak.
“Officer Miller,” Vance said over her shoulder. “Secure the residence. Call the crime scene tech for luminol. And cuff them both.”
Judith took a step back, her fragile facade instantly dissolving into venomous indignation. “Excuse me? You are in my home! You do not have the right to walk into this house and speak to my daughter like a criminal! I know Judge Harrison personally. I play bridge with—”
“Judith Merritt,” Detective Vance said, pulling a laminated sheet from her coat, “you are under arrest for conspiracy to commit aggravated assault, reckless endangerment, and false imprisonment. Sloane Merritt, you are under arrest for aggravated assault with a deadly weapon and tampering with physical evidence.”
Sloane shrieked as an officer seized her wrists, spinning her around and forcing her face-first against the antique wallpaper.
“Get your hands off me!” Sloane screamed, thrashing against the restraint. “Mother! Tell them! She fell! She fell on the coffee table!”
Detective Vance leaned in close to Sloane’s ear as the steel cuffs clicked shut with a vicious, metallic snap.
“She didn't fall on the coffee table, Sloane,” Vance whispered. “And you shouldn't have aimed for the camera's blind spot. Because there wasn't one.”
Judith stopped struggling. Her gaze whipped upward, past the grandfather clock, past the crown molding, straight to the small, dark aperture nestled beneath the top shelf of the oak bookcase.
For three seconds, absolute silence fell over the hallway.
Then, Judith whispered a single word into the glare of the squad lights:
*“Paige.”*
May you like
It was not a mother’s cry of regret. It was the hiss of a warden realizing that the prisoner had possessed the master key all along.
***
